Sondra,
Every now and then Mayhem (Rascal's brother, Chongo's half) gets finicky. He really doesn't eat as much as the other cats. Unlike JP's cat, mine will eat turkey, but are not a fan of chicken unless grilled and cooled. Then they might get rather pushy about getting some from the humans. (i.e. the claws come out)
I use a different diet from many from what I can figure out. I use Fancy Feast grilled and Royal Canin Adult Select (but kitten would be better for your cat) for wet, with all the Blue Wilderness Kibble (Selective Savor) dry they want. The boys are not fat, rather skinny, but very healthy.
When Holly and Dale are around they have been quite responsive to me and have helped a lot in the past.
What is Atari begging for? (hmmm, Who is Atari's father?????)
JP, Amanda's F3 Cappy is also a half brother to our boys. So it's 4 that I know about.